When the world's at stake,
go beyond the headlines.

National security. For insiders. By insiders.

National security. For insiders. By insiders.

Join War on the Rocks and gain access to content trusted by policymakers, military leaders, and strategic thinkers worldwide.

In Brief: The Dismissal of Sergei Shoigu

May 22, 2024
In Brief: The Dismissal of Sergei Shoigu
In Brief: The Dismissal of Sergei Shoigu

In Brief: The Dismissal of Sergei Shoigu

Alexandra Prokopenko, Janis Kluge, Maria Shagina, Dmitry Gorenburg, and Julian Waller
May 22, 2024
A lot happens every day. Alliances shift, leaders change, and conflicts erupt. With In Brief, we’ll help you make sense of it all. Each week, experts will dig deep on a single issue happening in the world to help you better understand it.***Last week, Russian President Vladimir Putin reassigned Sergei Shoigu from defense minister to secretary of the national security council, effectively dismissing him from his post of twelve years. Putin picked Andrei Belousov, an economist and technocrat with no military experience, to take his place. Amidst a renewed Russian offensive in Ukraine, we asked five experts to explain the significance of this reshuffling. Read more below. Alexandra Prokopenko Fellow Carnegie Russia Eurasia CenterVladimir Putin’s priority is war, and a war of attrition is won by economics. Andrei Belousov could be an ideal candidate for this. He favors stimulating demand through the budget, meaning military spending will likely increase. Belousov can be called one of the architects of Russia’s militarized economy. Compared to figures like Sergey Shoigu and his detained deputy Temur Ivanov, Belousov appears ascetic. Optimization will likely occur by reducing tank biathlons, construction such as the Patriot Park, and other costly “toy soldier” games Shoigu enjoyed.However, there are challenges. Despite his long bureaucratic career, Belousov has never managed anything significant; presidential aides and deputy prime ministers are limited by their staffs, and the Ministry of Economic Development does not handle large budgets. Additionally, Belousov lacks his own team. The military-industrial complex and army are now managed by heavyweights like Valery Gerasimov, Sergey Shoigu, Denis Manturov, Dmitry Medvedev, and Alexey Dyumin, making intra-elite conflicts inevitable, especially given Belousov’s bad temper. His task is to avoid the mistakes of Soviet Defense Minister Dmitry Ustinov: ensure the military-industrial complex runs smoothly and efficiently without bankrupting the country. Janis Kluge Senior Associate The German Institute for International and

Members-Only Content

This article is reserved for War on the Rocks members. Join our community to unlock exclusive insights and analysis.

A lot happens every day. Alliances shift, leaders change, and conflicts erupt. With In Brief, we’ll help you make sense of it all. Each week, experts will dig deep on a single issue happening in the world to help you better understand it.***Last week, Russian President Vladimir Putin reassigned Sergei Shoigu from defense minister to secretary of the national security council, effectively dismissing him from his post of twelve years. Putin picked Andrei Belousov, an economist and technocrat with no military experience, to take his place. Amidst a renewed Russian offensive in Ukraine, we asked five experts to explain the significance of this reshuffling.

Become a Member
Already a member? Sign in
Warcast
Get the Briefing from Those Who've Been There
Subscribe for sharp analysis and grounded insights from warriors, diplomats, and scholars.