Sign in to War on the Rocks or create an account
Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google Sign in with Twitter Sign in with LinkedIn

Sign in or sign up with email

Login
Remember me

Forget? | Register
Back to Login | Register
Please enter a username.
Enter your email address to create an account
A password will be e-mailed to you.
Hide from Public

Skip to content
War on the Rocks
War on the Rocks
Hasty Ambush
  • About
  • Editors
  • Contributors
  • Contact
  • Shop
  • National Security Jobs
  • Blogs
    • Art of War
    • Charlie Mike
    • Hasty Ambush
    • Molotov Cocktail
    • #NatSec2016
  • Special Series
    • Beyond Offset
    • Strategic Outpost
    • The Schoolhouse
    • (W)ARCHIVES
  • Podcasts
  • Commentary
Login
Hasty Ambush

Noonan at US News: The Non-Scandal of Special Operations Forces

Michael Noonan
January 22, 2014
8722307871_cbbc0bc614_b

Related Articles

Dispelling Myths About Special Operations Forces

How the OSS Shaped the CIA and American Special Ops

Women in Ground Combat Units: Where’s the Data?

Print Friendly
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Google+
  • LinkedIn

Professor and former State Department Counselor Eliot A. Cohen, writing about the elite British Special Air Service in his 1978 book “Commandos and Politicians,” noted that:

The SAS fought in Malaya, Borneo, Muscat and Oman, largely as a counter-insurgency force but also as jacks of all trade ready for various delicate and dangerous tasks. The British government kept their activities secret, hoping to use them as a discreet, non-publicized intervention force. Ironically, the curtain of secrecy surrounding the SAS made it an intriguing topic for speculation. Its reputation grew in inverse proportion to what was known about it, to the point that the government could use it effectively as a symbol because of the mystery surrounding it.

While today there is a great deal more information available about such elite formations – particularly due to the rapidity with which information is gathered and disseminated in the information age and their place in popular culture due to films and video games – there still remains a great deal of mystery and secrecy surrounding such units. Some of this shroud is completely appropriate and understandable in order to provide legitimate operational security for such unit members and their missions, but others argue that this sometimes goes too far.

 

Read the rest at U.S. News and World Report.

Michael P. Noonan, a WOTR contributor, is director of the national security program at the Philadelphia-based Foreign Policy Research Institute.
Photo credit: USASOC News Service

Promoted Stories

News from idealmedia.com

  • Commentary

    Dispelling Myths About Special Operations Forces

  • Commentary

    How the OSS Shaped the CIA and American Special Ops

  • Charlie Mike

    Women in Ground Combat Units: Where’s the Data?

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

LOGIN

One thought on “Noonan at US News: The Non-Scandal of Special Operations Forces”

  1. LongTabSigO says:
    February 24, 2014 at 5:08 pm

    What makes me laugh out loud as i read this sort of stuff is that folks like the terse Mr Turse at The Nation think everyone in “SOF” is a “killa”.

    When I commanded a TSOC Signal Detachment and launched a 2-man comm team to the Balkans or Africa, i “deployed SOF”. However it is fair to say that i didn’t put a lethal assassination team on the ground.

    That’s why reports like Turse’s should be mocked as so much hysterical screaming.

    Log in to Reply
Copyright © War on the Rocks
RSS FEED / HOME
✖
  • LongTabSigO

    What makes me laugh out loud as i read this sort of stuff is that folks like the terse Mr Turse at The Nation think everyone in “SOF” is a “killa”.

    When I commanded a TSOC Signal Detachment and launched a 2-man comm team to the Balkans or Africa, i “deployed SOF”. However it is fair to say that i didn’t put a lethal assassination team on the ground.

    That’s why reports like Turse’s should be mocked as so much hysterical screaming.

  • Cancel reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.

    LOGIN

    Cancel